My View

DeConto: What Nanny taught me about God

October 18, 2013 

Jesse James DeConto


A year ago this month, my Nanny died. I studied philosophy in college and have a seminary degree. I get paid to write about faith. Nanny never went to college. She cast a suspicious eye toward the church. One of her gifts to the world was an irreverent wit. My maternal grandmother taught me as much as about God as anyone.

When I was a freshman in college, Nanny replied to my letter asking questions about her beliefs, urging her to trust Jesus. Matriarch to six children, 11 grandchildren, and three great-grandchildren, rising 4 feet, 11 inches off the floor, Nanny had command over some of the best life had to offer: kind blue eyes, a cabinet full of sugary cereals, terrific back rubs, and hand-breaded chicken cutlets fried in butter. Yet I had something she needed: Jesus.

“The difference between being old and young is the young are idealists and the old are realists,” she’d written to me. “I was there, once. Life, if you pay attention, changes you. If it doesn’t, then you haven’t grown. I know you think I’m probably going to hell for the way I feel. It’s OK for you to feel the way you do. It’s also OK for me to feel the way I do.

“Why should I believe in the Son when the Father directs and guides me?” she wrote. “God is there, so is Santa Claus, so is love. God to me means I love you, I will never hurt you, I will always help you, I will always be there for you. I love you dearly, Jesse, and would never want to cause you concern. Please accept that I’m very happy in my faith, even though it may seem different from yours. I have no intentions of going to hell, even though I like the heat. And, Jess, another thing: You could never offend me by being honest, but closed-minded is something else. … Yours is not the only religion, and yours is not the only way of life. Open up your heart and accept all. Just accept. It doesn’t have to change you or them. God made all of us. He has his reasons. In our lifetime, we may never understand what they are. But we do know he made all of us, he gave us different thoughts and different religions. None of us know his plan. So just accept. I love you, Numero Uno. — Nanny.”

I’d never heard such complicated theological ideas from Nanny before. I counted on her for instant apple-cinnamon oatmeal packets and Marshmallow Fluff. Was there something to this? Could it be that the differences between people, even religious differences, were somehow grounded in Creation, God’s stamping on us his own image?

Leading up to Thanksgiving 2011, the feisty little woman fought for months to stay at her condo in Florida, but the family finally forced her to move here to Durham, where Mom could take care of her and Poppy. They were surrounded by us five of her grandkids, two granddaughters-in-law, and three great granddaughters. We hope Nanny felt loved in her last days.

Nanny’s imminent death had Mom thinking about the Great Sadness of her family, another death, when my 20-year-old uncle just went to bed one night and never woke up. I was still a baby. Mom had just left the Catholic church and “gotten saved,” and she was worried about her family’s eternal destiny. Just before her brother died, she’d asked him if he knew he’d go to heaven one day.

“It’s OK,” he said. “I’m still Catholic, and I believe in Jesus, just like you.”

“You do?” she’d said. “Oh, I’m so happy to hear you say that.”

“That meant everything to me after he died,” Mom had told me, with Nanny on her deathbed, “to know that he’d be in heaven. But now, with my mother, I don’t think that way anymore. I just leave it in God’s hands.”

“Tell mom how I feel,” Nanny had written on the outside of the envelope, with that letter she’d sent me 18 years ago.

“Remember that letter I sent you, Nan, trying to convert you?” I said to her a few months before her death.

“Everyone was always trying to convert me,” she said. “You were so intense about religion. I worried about you.”

No one was trying to convert her anymore. We’d seen good and bad, divinity and sin, love and bitterness in her, just like in everyone else. We hope her salvation doesn’t depend on anything she did or didn’t do, believed or didn’t believe, but only on a Creator who loves her.

Maybe this is what it means to follow the Slain Lamb, the Suffering Servant: We give up the power to try and change even our 80-pound grandmothers, and we simply love. We leave the saving to Jesus, and we love. That alone is a calling beyond our capability. The best we can do is to reflect what grace we’ve been given, little moons for the Sun.

Jesse James DeConto is a writer and musician living in Walltown. This column is adapted from his memoir, “This Littler Light: Some Thoughts on NOT Changing the World,” due out from Cascade Books this December. For more information, visit

Chapel Hill News is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service